Pj Whelihans Grill Room

If you are looking for the ultimate neighborhood gathering spot in the heart of the pines, P.J. Whelihan’s in Medford Lakes is a South Jersey staple that delivers every time. Housed in a charming, rustic log-cabin style building that perfectly fits the Medford Lakes aesthetic, this location manages to feel like a cozy retreat while pulsing with the high-energy atmosphere of a premier sports bar.

The history of P.J. Whelihan’s is a true local success story. Founded in 1983 by Bob Platzer in the Poconos, the group was named as a tribute to Platzer’s grandfather, Peter Joseph Whelihan. Since then, it has grown into a regional powerhouse known for its community involvement and its commitment to “food, drinks, and fun.” The Medford Lakes location, specifically, has long served as a “community living room” where locals gather for everything from post-youth-sports dinners to late-night celebrations.

Features & Highlights

The heartbeat of P.J.’s is its award-winning wing program. Whether you go for the “Famous Fries” (Old Bay seasoned with a side of melted American cheese sauce) or the jumbo bone-in wings tossed in one of their signature sauces like Hot-n-Honey or Copper Lager BBQ, you are experiencing a South Jersey tradition. The menu is a “New American” powerhouse, featuring Certified Angus Beef burgers, fresh salads, and surprisingly upscale mains like fire-grilled salmon.

For the beer enthusiast, the bar is a massive draw, boasting an impressive 48 draft lines. This includes their signature house beer, PJW Copper Lager, brewed specifically for them by Victory Brewing Company. The interior is packed with dozens of HD TVs, ensuring there isn’t a bad seat in the house for game day. If you prefer the fresh air, they offer a comfortable outdoor seating area where you can enjoy the Medford Lakes vibe. With a daily Happy Hour (Mon-Fri, 4-6 PM) and a staff that treats everyone like a regular, it’s no wonder this spot remains a local favorite.

Details can change — check the site or socials for the latest menus, hours, and events.