Old Oar House Irish Pub

If you’re looking for a spot that feels like a genuine slice of Dublin dropped right into the heart of Millville, the Old Oar House Irish Pub is a must-visit. Located on North High Street in the historic Glasstown Arts District, this is the kind of pub that understands the “neighborhood” assignment perfectly.

The building itself is a piece of history, dating back to 1883. The owners have done a painstaking job of recreating the vibe of an old Philadelphia-style Irish pub. Inside, you’re greeted by a dimly lit, cozy atmosphere featuring original pressed-tin ceilings, dark wainscoted walls, and wooden booths that practically invite you to settle in for a long session.

Features & Ambiance

The centerpiece of the pub is a custom wrap-around bar that anchors the room. For the beer enthusiast, the tap list is a serious draw—they boast an impressive 36 draft lines. You’ll find the required staples like Guinness and Harp poured to perfection, but they also lean into the local craft scene, frequently featuring brews from nearby Glasstown Brewing and Cape May Brewing.

The menu is a “greatest hits” of Irish comfort food blended with American pub favorites. You can’t go wrong with the Guinness Irish Stew or the Shepherd’s Pie, but their Corned Beef (offered as a traditional entrée with cabbage or in a loaded Reuben) is a local legend. If you’re there for a lighter bite, the Reuben bites and house-made soups are consistently top-notch.

One of the best-kept secrets in Millville is their all-season outdoor beer garden. It’s fenced-in and rustic, providing a great spot for seasonal dining and a bit of fresh air.

Entertainment & Events

The Old Oar House is a hub for the local community. It serves as a reliable pre- or post-show landing spot for the Levoy Theatre across the street. They keep the energy high with Live Music every Friday and Saturday night, and if you fancy yourself a singer, their Karaoke nights (typically every other Wednesday) are a staple of the local nightlife.