Highland Tavern

If you want to understand the soul of Gloucester City, you don’t go to a chain restaurant—you go to The Highland Tavern. Tucked away on Orlando Avenue in a quiet residential neighborhood, this place is the definition of a “hidden gem.” From the outside, it looks like a modest house (because it originally was one), but step inside, and you’ll find one of the most authentic, welcoming dive bars in South Jersey.

This isn’t a place that relies on gimmicks or modern trends. It’s a “Gloucester City Best Kept Secret” that earns its reputation through cold beer, great prices, and a community vibe that makes you feel like a regular the second you walk in. The history here is deep—originally a farmhouse built in the late 18th century, it became a speakeasy during Prohibition before officially becoming a legal tavern in 1933. That history is palpable in the worn wood and the no-nonsense, comfortable atmosphere.

The Drink Situation

The Highland is a beer drinker’s paradise, but not in a pretentious “snifter and tasting notes” kind of way. This is a place for ice-cold domestics and a surprisingly solid rotation of craft options. They respect the classics—you will always find a crisp pint of Miller Lite or Yuengling—but they also feature seasonal craft brews on tap (like Southern Tier’s French Toast Ale or local Jersey favorites).

It’s the kind of bar where the bartenders know how to pour a proper Guinness and aren’t afraid to mix a strong, simple cocktail. If you are looking for a $15 artisanal mixology experiment, keep walking. But if you want a beer that’s actually cold and a mixed drink that doesn’t skimp on the liquor, this is your spot.

The Food & Vibe

Do not sleep on the food here. The menu is classic pub comfort done right. The Wings are frequently cited as some of the best in the area—crispy, saucy, and exactly what you want alongside a pitcher of beer. Another standout is the New England Clam Chowder, a surprising but legendary menu item that locals swear by. They also serve up hearty sandwiches, mini panzarottis, and bar pies that hit the spot late at night.

The vibe is pure neighborhood tavern. There’s a pool table that sees constant action (join a game if you’re brave enough), a jukebox loaded with rock and country classics, and dart boards. It’s a place where the music is good, the conversation is loud, and the pretension is non-existent.

Details can change — check the site or socials for the latest menus, hours, and events.