Donny’s Mays Landing Inn

If you’re looking for the definition of a “hidden gem” in Atlantic County, you’ll find it at Donny’s Mays Landing Inn. Tucked away on Mill Street, just a stone’s throw from the Great Egg Harbor River, Donny’s is the quintessential neighborhood tavern that reminds you why South Jersey’s local bar scene is so special. It’s unpretentious, welcoming, and feels like the kind of place where the stools have stories to tell.

The atmosphere at Donny’s is rooted in that classic “inn” heritage—cozy, comfortable, and a bit nostalgic. It’s the type of spot where the lighting is just right, the service is genuinely friendly, and you can actually hear the person sitting next to you. Whether you’re a local regular or a traveler passing through the historic district of Mays Landing, you’re treated like you’ve been coming there for years.

Features & Highlights

While the kitchen may be modest in size, the output is highly regarded by those in the know. Donny’s is frequently praised for its homemade comfort food, specifically their burgers and daily specials that lean into traditional tavern fare. It’s the kind of menu that doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel—it just does the classics really, really well.

The bar itself is a sanctuary for fans of a great pour. They are known for a solid beer selection and cocktails that are mixed with a heavy hand and a friendly smile. For sports fans, it’s a premier local hub to catch the game without the overwhelming noise of a corporate wings-and-rings joint. With its central location and “come-as-you-are” attitude, Donny’s remains a cornerstone of Mays Landing’s social life, proving that sometimes the best nights out are the ones that keep it simple.

Details can change — check the site or socials for the latest menus, hours, and events.