Name: Lillo's Tomato Pies
Address: 157 S Burlington St, Gloucester City, New Jersey, 08030, United States
Telephone: (856) 349-7177

Bar Description

If you are looking for an incredible combination of highly praised food and a great neighborhood bar experience, Lillo’s Tomato Pies in Gloucester City is an absolute must visit. Originally making massive waves and earning viral fame with their first location in Hainesport, the Paxia family decided to expand and take over the beloved former Thomas Murphy’s Pub location on South Burlington Street. They brought their famous Trenton style tomato pies and massive cheesesteaks to Gloucester City, and thankfully for DrinkSJ readers, they kept the bar fully operational.

When you walk inside, you will find a cozy, old school pizzeria atmosphere that blends perfectly with a classic neighborhood tavern layout. They updated the space with fresh graphics and a great mural while keeping the comfortable core of the old pub intact. The dining room buzzes with a welcoming, family friendly energy. It is important to note that while they do accept credit cards, they offer a discount for cash, so hitting the ATM beforehand is a smart move.

Since the focus here is the bar, you will be thrilled to know that Lillo’s offers a fantastic draft beer selection to pair with your meal. It is not a massive cocktail lounge, but rather a perfect setup for enjoying a cold pint with a slice of pizza. Their draft lines feature excellent local and regional craft options, such as Cape May Brewing Company IPAs, Golden Road Mango Cart, and seasonal favorites like Orange Crushin’ It, alongside reliable staples like Yuengling Traditional Lager. It is exactly what you want when you are settling in for a hearty meal.

Speaking of the food, the menu is completely legendary. The main attraction is their authentic Trenton tomato pie, which features a thin, crispy, zero flop crust with the cheese placed on the bottom and a rich, crushed tomato sauce ladled on top. If you prefer a smaller pizza for yourself, they offer an excellent 12 inch tavern style bar pie. However, many people visit strictly for their cheesesteaks. The signature cheesesteak is packed with a staggering 16 ounces of ribeye and a quarter pound of cheese. They also serve an incredibly popular hot honey pepperoni chicken cheesesteak, massive orders of jumbo wings, and hearty salads.

Ultimately, Lillo’s Tomato Pies in Gloucester City delivers an amazing experience. It perfectly merges a famous food destination with a relaxed local watering hole, ensuring you leave completely full and highly satisfied.