If you are looking for a historic, quintessential shore tavern experience right in the heart of Stone Harbor, Fred’s Tavern and Liquor Store is an absolute landmark. Located on 96th Street, this venue has been a beloved staple for locals and vacationers since 1935. Now in its fourth generation of family ownership, originally founded by Fred Menzel, it has completely retained its authentic, casual charm. The tavern has even built a worldwide cult following over the decades just from their classic branded t shirts. Whether you want to grab lunch after a morning on the sand or need a spot that stays open late, the atmosphere is always relaxed and welcoming.
The Drink Experience: Because DrinkSJ is focused on the bar, you will be very pleased with what Fred’s has to offer. They pour a very solid mix of craft beers and classic domestic favorites. On draft, you can regularly find excellent local and regional craft options like Tonewood Brewing’s Fuego IPA, Kona Big Wave, and Lawson’s Finest Liquids, alongside reliable staples like Yuengling. The bartenders are quick and ready to mix up classic cocktails without any pretension. A major bonus for patrons is their attached liquor store. If you need to grab drinks to go for your next beach day, their shop is fully stocked with everything from cold package goods to modern THC infused beverages.
Classic Tavern Food: The kitchen keeps the focus on familiar, comforting bar food done exceptionally well. Regulars highly recommend their cheesesteaks, which are consistently praised as some of the best on the island. The menu is loaded with shareable bites perfect for a beach crowd, including potato skins loaded with cheddar and bacon, huge orders of buffalo wings, and soft pretzel bites served with a side of warm beer cheese. They also serve excellent burgers, chicken quesadillas, and fresh salads.
The Vibe: Fred’s Tavern is exactly what a beach town watering hole should be. It is unpretentious, completely casual, and incredibly friendly. Guests can choose between the main bar, the dining room, or their outdoor patio space. It often stays open later than many other spots in town, making it a very fun, lively place to gather with a crowd after the sun goes down.
