Anthonys Pizza Town

Anthony’s Pizza Town: A South Jersey Institution

If you’re hunting for an authentic slice of vintage New Jersey dining with a side of ice-cold beer, look no further than Anthony’s Pizza Town in Bordentown. This beloved institution is far more than just a pizzeria; it’s a time capsule with serious culinary chops and a true local neighborhood feel.

The Enthusiast’s Review

Stepping into Anthony’s is an experience in pure nostalgia. Opened back in 1977, this fixture along US-130 has proudly resisted modern renovation, welcoming patrons with its unmistakable vintage 70s “Italian Cantina” decor. You’ll find orange tile, retro wallpaper, and, perhaps most famously, walls absolutely covered in Elvis memorabilia. It’s the kind of place with a big flashing neon sign outside and a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere inside—complete with small TVs for catching the game.

The true heart of the venue is the owner, Anthony, a high-energy, authentic Italian character who is often seen tossing fresh dough. Patrons consistently rave about the fast, friendly service and Anthony’s welcoming personality.

The Bar & Kitchen Features

While the food is the main event, the venue holds its own as a perfect spot for a casual drink, offering a selection of Beer and Wine Only. Grab a cold bottled beer or a draft Miller and settle in for some of the best Italian-American comfort food in the region.

Must-Try Features:

• The Pizza: Anthony’s is renowned for its authentic homemade Sicilian Pizza and the flawless, crunchy-crusted Tomato Pie. Many enthusiasts claim it’s the best Sicilian in New Jersey.

• Beyond the Pie: The expansive menu includes excellent Cheesesteaks, classic Italian cold subs, and full pasta dishes—look out for local regional touches like calling penne “pencil points.”

• Amenities: The venue offers dine-in seating, fast takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery. It’s spacious enough for groups and families.

• Good to Know: While Anthony famously prefers cash (keeping that old-school vibe alive), they do accept credit card and NFC payments for larger orders.

Details can change — check the site or socials for the latest menus, hours, and events.