Historic Smithville Inn

If you’re visiting Historic Smithville and skipping The Smithville Inn, you are missing the anchor of the entire village. This isn’t just a “tourist trap” restaurant resting on its laurels; it’s a genuinely impressive culinary landmark that balances its massive history with a surprisingly modern and sophisticated bar program. Originally built in 1787 as a stagecoach stop by James Baremore, the Inn feels every bit the part—cobblestone paths, roaring fireplaces, and a rustic aesthetic that transports you back to the colonial era the moment you step inside.

However, don’t let the “historic” label fool you into expecting a dusty, old-fashioned experience. The vibe here is vibrant and polished, particularly if you head to the Baremore Tavern, the dedicated bar area within the Inn. It operates with a speakeasy-style energy that feels distinctly different from the main dining rooms. The lighting is dim, the wood is dark, and the service is sharp.

Drinks & Dining Experience

For a bar enthusiast, the cocktail program is the real surprise here. They aren’t just pouring standard mixed drinks; they are executing a high-level craft menu. Expect seasonal creations that lean into complex flavors—recent standouts include the Fireside Old Fashioned (with black walnut bitters and muddled cherries) and the Speakeasy Sour (featuring Sazerac whiskey and a red wine floater). They also feature a “Spirit Free” menu for non-drinkers that is just as thoughtful, using ingredients like butterfly pea flower tea and seedlip spice.

On the beer front, they support the local scene well. You will often find their exclusive Baremore Devil IPA (brewed by nearby Pinelands Brewing Co.) on draft, alongside other rotating craft selections and reliable domestics.

The food matches the atmosphere—”Old World Aesthetics Meets New American Cuisine.” The menu is robust, featuring everything from their famous Chicken Pot Pie (a dish that has practically cult status in the area) to upscale entrees like Short Ribs and fresh seafood. Whether you are there for a romantic dinner by the lake or a burger and a beer in the Tavern, the quality is consistent, and the atmosphere is unmatched in the region.

Details can change — check the site or socials for the latest menus, hours, and events.